516-729-7963
74a Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY for Rent

Retail - For Rent
1/21
2,830 SF | 1 Space

74a Montauk Hwy
Amagansett, NY 11930


HIGHLIGHTS

  • Iconic Amagansett Restaurant For Lease
  • Turnkey 126+ Seat Indoor / Outdoor Dining on 0.77 Acres
  • South-of-the-Highway Restaurant Opportunity
  • Turnkey Kitchen + Full Prep Infrastructure
  • Renovated Building With Indoor/Outdoor Flow
  • Ample Parking + Functional Site Layout

OVERVIEW

South-of-the-Highway Restaurant Opportunity – Located south of the highway in Amagansett, this fully built-out restaurant offers a rare turnkey leasing opportunity in one of the Hamptons’ most desirable dining corridors. The layout accommodates 126 seats across interior dining and an expansive open patio (96 Inside / 30 Outside - can be altered accordingly), creating a flexible service environment well suited for both seasonal peaks and year-round operation. Turnkey Kitchen + Full Prep Infrastructure – The oversized kitchen space includes newer professional equipment and updated mechanicals, allowing an operator to step in with minimal upfront investment. A full finished basement with legal prep area supports catering, expanded food production, and event service, while multiple walk-ins enhance operational efficiency. Office space and back-of-house areas further support day-to-day management and staffing. Renovated Building With Indoor/Outdoor Flow – The ±2,830sf main level is complemented by a finished lower level, creating a practical layout for both guest-facing and operational uses. Renovated in 2020, the property features updated systems, ceramic tile flooring, central A/C, and gas service. The open patio extends the dining experience outdoors and provides additional seating capacity and private event flexibility. Ample Parking + Functional Site Layout – Set on 0.77 acres, the property includes 31 on-site parking spaces, including accessible parking, providing convenient guest access and operational ease. The site’s size and layout support smooth circulation for both staff and patrons - an increasingly rare amenity in Hamptons restaurant locations. Flexible Lease Terms – The property is currently offered with flexible lease structures, including both seasonal and multi-year availability. A multi-year term is offered at $240,000 base rent asking + $700,000 key money asking (which would provide ownership of all of the equipment), and a full season option at $175,000 base rent (seasonal only available for 2026). This turnkey restaurant opportunity in one of the most supply constrained regions in the Hamptons. Amagansett, with its high-caliber, small-town feel, is eagerly waiting for its next iconic restaurant. SURROUNDING TENANTS: Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee, Meetinghouse, Warm, Amagansett Hardware, Stephen Talkhouse, La Fondita, Zakura Inquire with the Hamptons Commercial RE Team for additional information.

RENTAL DETAILS

SPACE AVAILABLE

2,830 SF

# OF SPACES

1

RENT RATE (MO)

Request Info for Rent

RENT RATE (YR)

Request Info for Rent

LEASE TYPE

TBD

LEASE LENGTH

Negotiable

AVAILABLE

Now

BUILDING DETAILS

PROPERTY TYPE

Retail

PROPERTY SUBTYPE

Restaurant

TOTAL BUILDING SIZE

2,830 SF

YEAR BUILT

1960

PARKING SPACES

31

LAND DETAILS

LAND ACRES

0.79 AC

LAND SF

34,412.4 SF

ZONING

-

ASK ABOUT THIS PROPERTY

Lee MinetreeSaunders & AssociatesMore Info
516-729-7963

By clicking the button, you agree to Showcase's Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.

Lee MinetreeSaunders & AssociatesMore Info
516-729-7963

By clicking the button, you agree to Showcase's Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.