52-Acre Horse Farm
To Be Offered In 6 Parcels & Entirety
Prime Future Homestead Parcels
4-Bed Farmhouse, 40x80 Shop W/ Apartment, Indoor & Outdoor Riding Arenas
14-Stall Barn, Fenced Pasture, Rolling Fields, Pond
Bethlehem Twp., Stark Co., Fairless LSD
Also Selling: 1989 Wagoneer, Polaris Ranger, Tractors, Equipment, Horse Tack, Collectibles & More!
Live Auction With Online Bidding Available On Real Estate And Select Items
Absolute auction, all sells to the highest bidders on location: 6395 Sherman Church Ave. SW, Navarre, OH 44706 Directions: From I-77 take Fohl St. exit SW, head east for one half mile then turn left onto Sherman Church Ave. to auction. Watch for KIKO signs.
Saturday, October 18, 2025, 10:00 AM
Real Estate Sells at 11:00 AM
Open House: Monday, October 13, 2025, 4:00-6:00 PM
Horse Tack, Collectibles Start Selling at 10:00 AM
Wagoneer & Equipment to Sell at 12:00 PM
Real Estate: 52-acre horse farm to be offered in 6 parcels and entirety. Improvements include a charming farmhouse, tucked away down a storybook tree-lined driveway, with 4 bedrooms, and 3 full baths. The farmhouse also includes an eat-in kitchen, sunroom, formal dining room, study, main floor bathroom and family room. Full basement with laundry and fuel oil boiler heat. Detached 2-car garage. Also on the property is a decked out 40x80 drive-through shop building with a 12’H x 14’W overhead door, featuring a two-story apartment with central heat and A/C, kitchen, full bath, two offices, laundry, and living room, plus a tool room, yoga room, and a versatile flex space currently used as a private home gym. The 70x190 indoor horse arena has rubber with sand specialty footing and 16ft high ceilings. Other improvements include a 14-stall horse barn with double stalls, washroom, and tack room; 2-stall 4-H barn; a 30x34 storage building plus multiple lean-to buildings for equipment storage. Rolling fields and ideal building parcels.
Farm to be offered as follows:
Parcel 1: 12.8 acres with farmhouse, horse barn, riding arena, pond and outbuildings.
Parcel 2: 15.5 acres, future homestead parcel with 630’ of frontage on Brinker.
Parcel 3: 6.4 acres, ideal building parcel with 1,130 ft. frontage on the corner of Brinker and Sherman Church.
Parcel 4: 6.3 acres, ideal building parcel with 380’ frontage on Sherman Church.
Parcel 5: 6.3 acres, ideal building parcel with 410’ frontage on Sherman Church.
Parcel 6: 5 acres, ideal building parcel with 555’ frontage on Sherman Church.
Terms On Real Estate: 10% down auction day, balance due at closing. A 10% buyer’s premium will be added to the highest bid to establish the purchase price. Any desired inspections must be made prior to bidding. All information contained herein was derived from sources believed to be correct. Information is believed to be accurate but not guaranteed. Property to be offered as a Multi Par auction and sold whichever way it brings the most.
Auction By Order Of: Francesca Nicoletti, Successor Trustee of the Francesco G. and Joy E. Nicolette Revocable Trust
Auctioneers/Realtors: Peter Kiko, Sr., 330.705.5996, peter@kikocompany.com; Kristen Kiko, 330.234.7110, kristen@kikocompany.com; Jacob Whitacre, 330.417.9123, jake@kikocompany.com