5214 Old Lake Rd - Apartments FOR SALE


Geneva, OH 44041
$1,924,900 USD
234-430-4183
5214 Old Lake Rd, Geneva, OH for Sale
$1,924,900 USD
Apartments - FOR SALE
1/51
null | Request Cap Rate

5214 Old Lake Rd
Geneva, OH 44041


HIGHLIGHTS

  • Offers a rare 12-unit investment in Geneva-on-the-Lake blending stable income with short-term rental upside in a premier Lake Erie destination.
  • Positioned steps from Lake Erie and the Strip, the property provides walkable access to beaches, dining, shopping, and year-round amenities.
  • Combines long-term rentals with Airbnb & VRBO use, creating immediate cash flow & clear potential to increase revenue through operational upside.
  • Includes 12 two-bed, one-bath unites across three structures, featuring a condo-style building, ranch units, and a freestanding cottage.
  • Seven units are leased on month-to-month terms, offering flexibility to reposition, renovate, or increase rents based on future strategy.
  • Located in a high-demand vacation market with consistent tourism, supporting strong occupancy trends and long-term investment stability.

OVERVIEW

5214 Old Lake Road, Geneva-on-the-Lake, Ohio 44041 presents an exceptional investment opportunity in one of Northeast Ohio's most desirable vacation destinations. Situated on four parcels with stunning views of Lake Erie and panoramic vistas down the famous Geneva-on-the-Lake Strip, this unique property offers a rare combination of long-term rental income and short-term vacation rental potential. Comprised of 12 total rental units (two bed, one bath per unit), the property spans three buildings, including a three-story, six-unit condo-style building with Lake Erie views, six ranch-style units, and a charming freestanding cottage. Many units have been updated with premium finishes and modern improvements, making them highly attractive to both seasonal visitors and long-term tenants. Four units operate as monthly rentals generating consistent income, while several others are utilized as short-term rentals through Airbnb, VRBO, and direct bookings, creating excellent upside potential for increased revenue. Seven of the 12 units are currently occupied on month-to-month agreements, providing flexibility for an investor's future plans. Guests and tenants enjoy convenient access from both Old Lake Road and Lake Road, along with a prime, walkable location just steps from Lake Erie, Township Park, public beach access, and the entertainment district known as "The Strip." Restaurants, bars, shopping, live entertainment, wineries, and countless seasonal attractions are all within walking distance, making this a highly sought-after destination year after year. Whether looking to expand an investment portfolio, capitalize on the thriving vacation rental market, or implement a mixed-use income strategy, this Geneva-on-the-Lake property presents a rare opportunity in a location where demand continues to grow. Schedule a private showing to explore the full potential of this income-producing asset.

FOR SALE DETAILS

PRICE

$1,924,900 USD

PRICE/SF

$152 USD /SF

# OF UNITS

12

PRICE/UNIT

$160,408

CAP RATE

Request Cap Rate

% LEASED

55%

SALE TYPE

Investment

BUILDING DETAILS

PROPERTY TYPE

Multi-Family

PROPERTY SUBTYPE

Apartments

TOTAL BUILDING SIZE

-

STORIES

3

YEAR BUILT

1998

PARKING SPACES

-

LAND DETAILS

LAND ACRES

0.64 AC

LAND SF

27,878 SF

ZONING

C

APN/PARCEL ID

210300004500,210300004600,210300004900,210300005000

ASK ABOUT THIS PROPERTY

Danny DuvallBrokers Realty GroupMore Info
234-430-4183

By clicking the button, you agree to Showcase's Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.

Danny DuvallBrokers Realty GroupMore Info
234-430-4183

By clicking the button, you agree to Showcase's Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.